Google Gemini reviews Doctor Who - The Myth Makers
Doctor Who: The Myth Makers - A Mixed Mythical Adventure
"The Myth Makers" is a 1965 historical serial from Doctor
Who's classic era, part of the First Doctor's adventures.
Here's a breakdown to help you decide if you'd like to
embark on this journey through Trojan War myths:
Story
The TARDIS materializes in ancient Greece during the Trojan War.
The Doctor, Vicki, Steven, and Barbara find themselves caught
between the Greeks and the Trojans. The Doctor discovers
the Trojan War might be a fabricated story perpetuated
by the manipulative Medusa, a creature from another
world who feeds on human conflict. The companions
get embroiled in the legendary events as the
Doctor tries to expose the truth and prevent
further bloodshed.
Review
Strengths
Unique Blend of History and Myth: The story weaves
together elements of Greek mythology (Trojan War, Medusa)
with historical fiction (Trojan conflict), creating
an intriguing backdrop.
Focus on Companions: The companions play active roles
in the narrative, with Barbara's knowledge of history
proving valuable.
Humorous Elements: The serial has lighter moments
with the Doctor and companions adjusting to ancient
Greece, providing a balance to the historical drama.
Weaknesses
Missing Episodes: Unfortunately, episodes 2 and 3
exist only as photo reconstructions, which can
disrupt the narrative flow for modern viewers.
Limited Historical Accuracy: While inspired
by mythology, the depiction of the Trojan War
might not be entirely historically accurate.
Slow Pacing in Parts (Reconstructions):
The reconstructed sections might feel
slow at times, especially during exposition
scenes explaining the mythology and historical context.
Reception:
Positive: Praised for its unique blend of history
and myth, focus on the companions' roles,
and lighter humorous moments. Some fans also
enjoy the concept of the Doctor unraveling
a fabricated mythology.
Negative: Criticised for its missing episodes
that disrupt the narrative, limited historical
accuracy, and slow pacing in certain sections,
especially when relying on reconstructions.
Overall Thoughts:
"The Myth Makers" is an interesting experiment
in merging mythology and historical fiction
in Doctor Who. While the missing episodes
and looser approach to history might be
drawbacks, it offers a thought-provoking
exploration of warfare and the power of stories.
Would I recommend watching it?
For Fans of Classic Doctor Who: 6/10
(Especially those interested in historical settings
with a mythological twist
and enjoy seeing the companions in action)
For Fans of Modern Doctor Who: 4/10
If you're a die-hard fan of classic Doctor Who
and are willing to overlook the limitations
of lost episodes and reconstructions,
"The Myth Makers" might be worth checking out.
However, if you prefer fast-paced adventures
with complete narratives and strict historical
accuracy, you might find it slow and less engaging.
Additional Points to Consider:
This serial is significant for being the First Doctor's
first historical adventure, paving the way
for future historical stories in the show.
"The Myth Makers" is a 1965 historical serial from Doctor
Who's classic era, part of the First Doctor's adventures.
Here's a breakdown to help you decide if you'd like to
embark on this journey through Trojan War myths:
Story
The TARDIS materializes in ancient Greece during the Trojan War.
The Doctor, Vicki, Steven, and Barbara find themselves caught
between the Greeks and the Trojans. The Doctor discovers
the Trojan War might be a fabricated story perpetuated
by the manipulative Medusa, a creature from another
world who feeds on human conflict. The companions
get embroiled in the legendary events as the
Doctor tries to expose the truth and prevent
further bloodshed.
Review
Strengths
Unique Blend of History and Myth: The story weaves
together elements of Greek mythology (Trojan War, Medusa)
with historical fiction (Trojan conflict), creating
an intriguing backdrop.
Focus on Companions: The companions play active roles
in the narrative, with Barbara's knowledge of history
proving valuable.
Humorous Elements: The serial has lighter moments
with the Doctor and companions adjusting to ancient
Greece, providing a balance to the historical drama.
Weaknesses
Missing Episodes: Unfortunately, episodes 2 and 3
exist only as photo reconstructions, which can
disrupt the narrative flow for modern viewers.
Limited Historical Accuracy: While inspired
by mythology, the depiction of the Trojan War
might not be entirely historically accurate.
Slow Pacing in Parts (Reconstructions):
The reconstructed sections might feel
slow at times, especially during exposition
scenes explaining the mythology and historical context.
Reception:
Positive: Praised for its unique blend of history
and myth, focus on the companions' roles,
and lighter humorous moments. Some fans also
enjoy the concept of the Doctor unraveling
a fabricated mythology.
Negative: Criticised for its missing episodes
that disrupt the narrative, limited historical
accuracy, and slow pacing in certain sections,
especially when relying on reconstructions.
Overall Thoughts:
"The Myth Makers" is an interesting experiment
in merging mythology and historical fiction
in Doctor Who. While the missing episodes
and looser approach to history might be
drawbacks, it offers a thought-provoking
exploration of warfare and the power of stories.
Would I recommend watching it?
For Fans of Classic Doctor Who: 6/10
(Especially those interested in historical settings
with a mythological twist
and enjoy seeing the companions in action)
For Fans of Modern Doctor Who: 4/10
If you're a die-hard fan of classic Doctor Who
and are willing to overlook the limitations
of lost episodes and reconstructions,
"The Myth Makers" might be worth checking out.
However, if you prefer fast-paced adventures
with complete narratives and strict historical
accuracy, you might find it slow and less engaging.
Additional Points to Consider:
This serial is significant for being the First Doctor's
first historical adventure, paving the way
for future historical stories in the show.
Trackbacks
No Trackbacks
Comments
Display comments as Linear | Threaded